Fantasy Football Friday: No. 3 TE off the board in 2012?
Earlier this morning, I released my initial fantasy football rankings for 2012. One thing is certain: They will change a lot from now until the start of the 2012 NFL season.
At the top of my tight end rankings, you will find New England's Rob Gronkowski, who had arthroscopic surgery on his ankle this morning, and New Orleans' Jimmy Graham in the top two spots. And from site to site, that will (should) be the case.
As we do every Friday, we respond to a weekly fantasy football roundtable question.
This week's topic: Who should be the third tight end off the board in 2012 fantasy football drafts?
Kevin (follow on Twitter):
In my rankings, Jason Witten is a spot higher than Antonio Gates at No.'s 3 and 4, respectively. When drafting a tight end, however, my hope is to take the guy that goes last out of my top six (in order of my rankings): Gronkowski, Graham, Witten, Gates, Vernon Davis and Aaron Hernandez. I can see any of the next four after Gronkkowski and Graham finishing third at the position in fantasy points. Witten had five-year lows in receptions (79), targets (117) and receiving yards (942), but I expect him to bounce back in 2012. Especially if the Cowboys don't re-sign receiver Laurent Robinson, an unrestricted free agent, Witten may get a few more targets that would otherwise go to Robinson. Either way, I worry about Gates durability so I'll let someone else assume that risk. And again, I'd prefer to draft Davis or Hernandez, assuming the other four players are the first four tight ends off the board.
John (follow on Twitter):
The position of TE has expanded offensively of late. A few years ago it was pretty much Tony Gonzalez and maybe a few guys that had good years, but that was about it. Today, it's a different game, and there are several quality options. After Gronkowski and Graham, I think there are a lot of guys that are pretty close in value; guys like Vernon Davis, Jermichael Finley, Jason Witten, Aaron Hernandez, and Brandon Pettigrew are all solid options. Still, my number three TE would have to be Antonio Gates. Gates seemed to be emerging as the premiere TE in the league over the last few years, but has been so injury-plagued that it has kept him from truly separating himself. Gates' athleticism has made him either 1 or 1a for Philip Rivers, and anytime you have a TE that is a number one option for a quarterback, you have a guy worth having on your fantasy team. In spite of his injuries, I would take a chance on Gates. There is enough depth at TE now that you could likely get a guy like Owen Daniels or Greg Olson as a viable back up in the event that Gates does miss time.
Sean (follow on Twitter):
So to answer the big question on who I want as the 3rd TE off the board this year, it's ... drum roll ... Aaron Hernandez, and the beauty of Hernandez is that most likely Witten & Gates will likely both be gone before him. I wouldn't try to get too fancy though and wait on him too long. The main reason why I love Hernandez this year is because of the amount of balls Brady throws to his TEs. Hernandez only had 11 less receptions, and even better only less 11 targets than Gronkowski. Brady's numbers to his two big TEs: 169 receptions, 2,237 yds and 24 TDs. I'm not suggesting, we split these numbers 50/50, but I could see a scenario where Gronkowski gets a lot of extra attention and Hernandez surpasses him as the team's top TE. Randy Moss had a disappointing year after his 2007 ridiculous season and I could see the same thing happening to Gronkowski. Brady will throw the ball to whomever, and can make a star out of anyone even if they don't have a ton of talent. Look out Hernandez in 2012!
Dan (follow on Twitter):
If I have the chance to take the third tight end this year, I am grabbing Antonio Gates of the Chargers. Gates has been hobbled the last few years with the toe and other assorted injuries. Although he missed time last year, he still had 13 games with 778 yards and seven touchdowns, and not all of those games were quality starts. Gates was the prototype TE, and he is always the No. 1 target in the red zone.
Steve:
Aaron Hernandez should be third off the board. It's hard to imagine the second tight end from the Patriots, but the Pats are the best offense in the NFL at using the TE. Despite Gronkowski's record-setting performance last year, Hernandez was still was fifth in targets and fourth in receiving yards for the position. As defenses continue to adjust for Gronkowski, I'd expect it to open up more opportunties Hernandez. If Aaron Hernandez's number of targets goes up from the 113 he got this year, I'd forecast 1,000-1,100 yards and 10-12 TDs.
Related: Our 2012 Fantasy Football Mock Draft, 1.0
Previous Fantasy Football Friday Posts:
- Feb. 3: Which AFC West RB will have a better 2012 season: McFadden or Mathews?
- Jan. 27: Who should be the 2nd WR selected in Fantasy Football Drafts?
- Jan. 20: Who should be the No. 1 pick in 2012 Fantasy Football Drafts?
- Jan. 13: Will Tim Tebow finish in the top 12 in fantasy points among QBs in 2012?
- Jan. 6: Better Fantasy TE in 2012: Rob Gronkowski or Jimmy Graham?